SBP Blog

Hiroaki Sato featured in January 2016 issue of The London Review of Books

Michael Palmer - Wednesday, January 20, 2016

August Kleinzahler on translator of Kansuke Naka's The Silver Spoon and many more, Hiroaki Sato in the January 2016 edition of The London Review of Books. 

On Hiroaki Sato by August Kleinzahler

"The act of making a poem – and it is a made thing, like an Assyrian brooch or Bolognese sauce (thus the word makar for ‘poet’ in old Scots) – requires a large set of decisions, at least dozens, more likely hundreds, even in the shortest of poems. The translation of a poem from one language to another requires a large and not dissimilar range of decisions or, slender as the distinction may be, choices, in order to deliver the poem, still breathing, into a different language, culture and often era. There is a large and fascinating literature about the act and art of translation, often described metaphorically, as by Christopher Middleton: ‘The translator has to imagine his way on the tentacles of language through to the bedrock sea bottom of the imagination of his author.’ Some translators, like Middleton, are poets, most are not, but the capabilities needed to render a first-rate translation overlap with those required in the making of the original. A translator’s decisions involve overall tone, diction, syntactical arrangement, punctuation, rhythm, lexical intent, assorted phonic elements, organisation (shape, development), formal considerations like syllabic count, lineation and rhyme and other intangibles that rely on poetic intuition or instinct. There’s more than a touch of making one’s way in the dark, no guidebook to hand. A misstep or poor decision can be ruinous. Most translations, like most poems, fail."

The full text of this essay is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.

Read Review at






Like our blog? Please share it!


Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan

Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

China Smart

Essential essays on all things Chinese that inform and entertain travelers, students, and anyone working or living in China

Forty-Seven Samurai

One of the most spectacular vendettas ever: the history and haiku behind the mass-suicide featured in the 2013 film 47 Ronin

Oh, Tama!

A deeply eccentric novel about lives and connections—and a cat of course—in 1980s Tokyo: witty, offbeat, and strangely profound.

Tag Cloud

illustration japan times diy mfa author talk japanese classic book reviews book review zen monk in japan Culture how to order in japan new books foreword reviews simba osaka stone bridge cafe memoir writing ancient symbols book hoarding zen swastika author tour chinese literature suicide monk fred schodt janet pocorbba japan book will eisner forty seven samurai expert suehiro maruo photography otakuusa tracy franz luke patitsas welton gaddy a memoir Okinawan literature wife japan behavior jared cook giajin 47 ronin Chinese New Year china where igo book tour lions roar Second World War politics and prose michael emmerich verticle memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist china smart shun medoruma the asian review of books keanu reeves blurb dark horse monks wife memior peace symbol the hidden writer a memoir of sensei and me jing liu Korea photography astrology manners hitler symbol classic literature japanese people japanese travel poet criterion japan ravel association of jewish libraries osamu dazai PEN AWARD the japan society author signing Anime/Manga/Comics student teacher sensei japan restaurant bookstore journal' monks wife 2020 Olympics eli lieberman translators japanese to english pacific rim review of books donald richie danica davidson Japanese holidays Poetry shaimsen book tea japan etiquette buddhist symbols poetry of consciousness amys guide to bes tbehavior in japan Korea kyodo news Tokyo Olympics non-fiction japan travel Christianity kyoto Shoah Asian Studies gallery awa ripe mangoes china guide publishing janet pocorobba interfaith ningen shikkaku holden caufield reviews japanese craft Japanese literature chinese comics japanese cutlure japan travel guide lesley university takuma sminkey AAS china What You Don’t Know, What You Need to Know— A Past & Present Guide to History, Culture, Society, Language catcher in the rye asian review of books Chinese history understandind china through comics the lion king kyoto journal buddhist swastika a mejiro novel japan culture japanese instruments washington dc writing journal Christianity in Japan astro boy tricycle magazine japan travel etiquette japan trip oh tama zen monk wife travel etiquette japanese music japanese books forest gander journal of a zen monk's wife t.k. nakagaki international book award IBPA graphic novels Art/Design alan brill hippocampus magazine new release zen monk stone bridge press Alexandra Johnson jun hazuki Japan the fourth string a memoir of sensei and me book award the japan times new york events american shamisen japanese culture foreword indies Year of the Dog seppuku chinese trip evil nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara why we write podcast donald keene book publicity benjamin franklin awards center of east asian studies literary review zazen musical 1960's Japan tokyo haibun Olympics wanderlust announcement matcha traditional japanese instrument shamisen Basho's Narrow Road nova scotia finalist lucille cara Interview living in japan huffpost japanese history classic event paul mccarthy gaijin osamau tezuka traditional japanese instrumenet ancient symbol forty seven ronin japan memoir controversy japanese book chapters journal of a zen monk ibpa publishing university Travel amys guide to best behavior in japan sensei and me gaijinpot journal of a zen monks wife in japan learning shamisen internment kinokuniya event what do in japan literature fantasy literature 1960s Korea Children's Literature books Spring Festival Coming of Age Day china vacation min kahng bushido performance author event how to state of belief religion book signing japanese manners summer vacation japan books amy chavez alan moore etiquette frank beyer book talk gratitude in japan juddhism tk nakagaki dirt and water dazai 47 samurai Translation japanese translation rebecca otowa green tea in the woods of memory podcast hiroaki sato japan today china history Chinese culture mark gibeau author japanese bath literary prize japanese drunk namethetranslator kimba the white lion year of zen 4k Chinese Astrology osamu tezuka shamisen performance tea garden yukio mishima manji william f sibley forewrod reviews indies memoir kansuke naka polite a shameful life nhk traditional larry herzberg Nikolas Bunton janet pocrobba foreword indies award travel to japan japanese comics expat book blurb four immigrants Language china book japan visitor japan manners drinking in japan japan book review nara koto society henry kiyama university of chicago world literature today eastern and western philosophy koun publicity do it right and be polite UCLA pottery death 2019 miswest book review History award anime peace Japanese art budhist swastika Spirituality japanese customs the silver spoon diymfa tourist damian flanagan guide eating in japan VIZ hitlers cross black jack benjamin franklin award china travel best behavior in japan manga biography disney Basho book reading Japanese aesthetics brad hawley diary walt disney my year of dirt and water expat in japan foreigner in japan new york visitor japanese books in english tomoko aoyama travel Japan gaijin pot japanese instrument holocaust classic japanese literature pulitzer prize classic poetry japan guide ritual Children's Books jungle emperor leonard koren review bowing in japan hooked cross World War Two kris kosaka japanese etiquette hiaku buddhist priest travel literature comic history WWII manga buddhist japan custom travel manners ex pat literature behavior Ukiyo-e zen monks wife' Chiune Sugihara World War II hate awards the millions learning in japan China The Colorado Review japan food monk wife no longer human huffington post buddhism purification frederik schodt traditional japanese music how to travel in japan asia the buddhist swastika haiku rachel manley the fourth string film hitler nazi japan vacation mieko kanai the inland sea doris bargen