SBP Blog

The Association of Jewish Libraries reviews 'The Buddhist Swastika and Hitler's Cross'

Michael Palmer - Monday, November 11, 2019

"Buddhist priest and scholar Rev. Dr. T. K. Nakagaki delineates the history of the Swastika as both a positive symbol of peace and through the Nazi usage that has come to represent evil and darkness."

Big thanks to Eli Lieberman for his review of T.K. Nakagaki's The Buddhist Swastika and Hitler's Cross: Rescuing a Symbol of Peace from the Forces of Hate for the Association of Jewish Libraries. Here's the full review:

"Nakagaki, T. K. The Buddhist Swastika and Hitler’s Cross: Rescuing a Symbol of Peace from the Forces of Hate. Berkeley, CA: Stone Bridge Press, 2019. 199 pp. $18.95 (9781611720457).

In this book, Buddhist priest and scholar Rev. Dr. T. K. Nakagaki delineates the history of the Swastika as both a positive symbol of peace and through the Nazi usage that has come to represent evil and darkness. As Nakagaki demonstrates, the swastika as understood in Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, and specifically as it relates to Buddhist history in Japan and elsewhere, is always used to represent auspiciousness and good fortune. He surveys the history of its usage around the world as a historical symbol as well, in European and North America, ranging as far as parts of Africa and elsewhere. This survey is used to show that the symbol has had a positive meaning for far longer than the Nazi association with the symbol.

The Nazi usage was built on earlier Eurocentric usages that utilized the now discredited Aryan invasion theory which was used to explain the linguistic connections between European languages and Sanskrit in history. Nakagaki also separates the positive meaning of the swastika from the Nazi Hakenkruez, the term Hitler himself used to connect the Christian cross to his new meaning of the symbol of the swastika as the pursuit of Aryan victory and antisemitism.

At the end of his analysis of the meaning of the symbol in the 21st century context and its valences in different communities, both positive and negative, Nakagaki suggests example statements for museums and Hindu and Buddhist temples and other cultural centers. These statements explain the usage and history of the swastika in contexts in which the symbol does not stand for hatred, in order to increase peace and understanding. This book is recommended for all libraries, especially those that have strong Holocaust collections and collections on interfaith relations.

Eli Lieberman, Judaica librarian, HUC-JIR New York"

Grab a copy of the book here:


Like our blog? Please share it!


Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan

Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

China Smart

Essential essays on all things Chinese that inform and entertain travelers, students, and anyone working or living in China

Forty-Seven Samurai

One of the most spectacular vendettas ever: the history and haiku behind the mass-suicide featured in the 2013 film 47 Ronin

Oh, Tama!

A deeply eccentric novel about lives and connections—and a cat of course—in 1980s Tokyo: witty, offbeat, and strangely profound.

Tag Cloud

state of belief william f sibley Christianity ancient symbols japan trip alan brill award peace symbol musical Chinese Astrology drinking in japan green tea the asian review of books Japan UCLA Year of the Dog frederik schodt Japanese art author tour shun medoruma book blurb dazai black jack Tokyo Olympics 47 samurai the hidden writer will eisner university of chicago fantasy literature tomoko aoyama eli lieberman japanese craft death History internment book tour learning shamisen amys guide to bes tbehavior in japan travel Japan the lion king oh tama kyoto japanese manners 2020 Olympics giajin ex pat literature the japan times japanese etiquette traditional japanese instrument behavior buddhist priest world literature today guide chinese literature china smart walt disney poetry of consciousness jun hazuki monks wife religion luke patitsas hiroaki sato chapters World War Two memior best behavior in japan Art/Design monk benjamin franklin award Second World War zen monk in japan diymfa journal of a zen monk washington dc no longer human japan travel etiquette amy chavez dirt and water Language author talk ibpa publishing university keanu reeves juddhism gratitude in japan kris kosaka new release japan books japanese people new books the buddhist swastika 2019 kyoto journal Japanese literature japan ravel AAS suicide Poetry the silver spoon hitler ancient symbol announcement author signing criterion japan culture book signing hitler symbol osamu dazai expat in japan Chinese history manners tricycle magazine foreword indies shamisen do it right and be polite tokyo interfaith writing manji nova scotia film haiku pacific rim review of books japan memoir tea literary review year of zen china guide gaijin pot zen forty seven samurai fred schodt travel etiquette china where igo the inland sea japanese drunk book osamau tezuka china What You Don’t Know, What You Need to Know— A Past & Present Guide to History, Culture, Society, Language illustration publishing WWII monk wife Chiune Sugihara asian review of books new york Asian Studies chinese comics japanese translation how to travel in japan buddhist non-fiction haibun Children's Books the japan society kansuke naka Basho's Narrow Road finalist polite miswest book review japanese zen monks wife' journal of a zen monk's wife disney the fourth string hiaku living in japan expert janet pocorbba budhist swastika manga tracy franz Basho japanese instrument literature nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara kyodo news holocaust bookstore VIZ comic history chinese yukio mishima donald keene Coming of Age Day japan times japanese cutlure etiquette janet pocrobba a shameful life seppuku performance matcha Shoah journal of a zen monks wife in japan book award book reading huffpost tk nakagaki poet danica davidson books classic japanese literature t.k. nakagaki buddhist swastika four immigrants China Japanese aesthetics japanese book 47 ronin china travel travel to japan welton gaddy the millions book review travel manners author event memoir writing japanese classic japan book review sensei and me purification literary prize eating in japan World War II the fourth string a memoir of sensei and me photography gaijin simba ritual why we write podcast forty seven ronin new york events nazi japanese customs center of east asian studies Olympics stone bridge press 1960s Korea hippocampus magazine journal astrology japan restaurant traditional japanese instrumenet peace japan manners Travel diary kimba the white lion japan food foreword reviews what do in japan my year of dirt and water lucille cara visitor japanese culture wanderlust Ukiyo-e Nikolas Bunton japan today international book award doris bargen japan visitor summer vacation Alexandra Johnson holden caufield podcast brad hawley japan travel review classic forest gander mark gibeau japan etiquette japan travel guide diy mfa swastika bowing in japan japanese to english anime nara 1960's Japan memoir suehiro maruo gaijinpot a mejiro novel japanese books in english japanese bath michael emmerich min kahng how to forewrod reviews indies gallery awa Okinawan literature event henry kiyama Christianity in Japan japanese history osamu tezuka Japanese holidays alan moore awards zen monk wife janet pocorobba japanese books donald richie buddhist symbols association of jewish libraries astro boy PEN AWARD wife ningen shikkaku Children's Literature china book traditional japanese music pulitzer prize paul mccarthy nhk in the woods of memory author damian flanagan koto zen monk eastern and western philosophy foreword indies award Translation huffington post hate amys guide to best behavior in japan comics travel literature Anime/Manga/Comics The Colorado Review kinokuniya event verticle otakuusa china vacation learning in japan jared cook osaka understandind china through comics Spirituality 4k society Korea how to order in japan japan behavior stone bridge cafe tourist graphic novels hooked cross jing liu lesley university asia japanese music a memoir of sensei and me mieko kanai shamisen performance journal' monks wife ripe mangoes manga biography japan guide sensei book publicity blurb lions roar classic poetry namethetranslator leonard koren Interview reviews publicity japanese instruments koun memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist translators benjamin franklin awards Chinese culture japan custom frank beyer evil Korea photography Spring Festival shaimsen expat IBPA american shamisen book reviews dark horse classic literature Culture traditional book hoarding rebecca otowa trip zazen bushido rachel manley Chinese New Year jungle emperor pottery buddhism takuma sminkey foreigner in japan tea garden book talk japanese travel hitlers cross controversy japan book a memoir politics and prose larry herzberg catcher in the rye japan vacation china history student teacher