SBP Blog

The Daily Nebraskan reviews "Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun"

Michael Palmer - Thursday, January 12, 2017

Thank you to Evan Pille at the The Daily Nebraskan for his thoughtful review of Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun. Read the review below or check it out at The Daily Nebraskan.

PILLE: ‘Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun’ is honest, dark memoir
Evan Pille Nov 21, 2016 

“Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun,” a new memoir written by Homare Endo in Japanese and translated to English by Michael Brase, aims to reveal a forgotten truth behind the founding of modern China.

After the end of World War II, many Japanese people were living in formerly occupied lands in China. Among these people was Takuji Okubo, a chemist working in Changchun and the father of Homare Endo. For three years, the family lived and worked in the city, forbidden to leave due to a siege by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army.

Homare Endo is one of the few people who survived this event. “Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun” documents her life as a young girl in unbearable conditions – not only starvation, but also thievery among those caught in the siege. For the civilians living there, supplies ran out quickly. An estimated 300,000 people died from starvation. The toll of human suffering was incalculable.

Endo speaks of these things with painful honesty. She doesn’t bother to insinuate, and she doesn’t bother to hide the truth. There are things written in this book that are difficult to repeat aloud – haunting moments that stun the reader and stick in his or her mind long after the book is closed. This book is not a light read by any stretch, and it’s not a book written to make the events more palatable. Instead, they are laid bare and become a backdrop to a dark and despairing story.

But even in this, there are moments of respite. There are moments of happiness and hope, even if fleeting. Some are almost astounding, almost unbelievable. But the most powerful moments, the most innocent and pure, are small gestures. When she can’t handle any more, these gestures allow Homare Endo to survive. More importantly, they let her retain her humanity and, eventually, recover from the trauma that would plague her for decades to come.

Endo’s personal account allows for a measure of intimacy with the reader. Through her eyes, we see the loss of innocence and the struggle to live. With her perspective, the story is more than a retelling of a historical event. It depicts the humans behind it, the people who lived, suffered and died. Their story is at the heart of this book, a fact made clear in its words.

The language employed is generally plain. In many ways, this works to Endo’s advantage, as nothing is toned down for politeness, and nothing is turned up for effect. The horror is not dramatized or exploited for shock value. In fact, many of the bleakest moments are told as if they were just another detail of the story because in many ways, that’s what they were.

For the people living in the siege, it was another part of their daily reality, another fact of life. This sense of numbness reflects itself in the blunt nature of the memoir. It strives for honesty more than entertainment.

By and large, this is a noble trait. But there are some moments when the language is somewhat too plain. The translation from Japanese to English seems to have imparted some stiffness and formality to the narrative voice, and there are some moments that could be more impactful if the writing had been more elegant.

But the plain language does allow for easy reading. As heavy as the subject matter is, it’s delivered at a brisk and even pacing, and at no time was there any confusion about was happening. Ultimately, the focus is more on plot than language, with the characters and events at the center.

In the introduction of the memoir, Endo calls her book a “memorial to the dead, a memento of my fight to make the truth known.”

In many ways, Changchun is a forgotten tragedy, swept under the rug of history behind bigger wars and war crimes. In some ways, this has been intentional, as the Chinese government has suppressed knowledge of this event, knowledge that the People’s Liberation Army had once been the cause of so much suffering. Even today, no Chinese publisher has been willing to publish this book for fear of retribution.

That’s what makes “Japanese Girl at the Siege of Changchun” so important. It reveals a truth hidden for so long and brings to light stories of the people who suffered, the people who were forgotten. If nothing else, this memoir is a historical record of significant value. But it’s more than that. It’s a reminder of how far human apathy can sink, the destructive power of selfishness and the necessity of empathy. It’s a reminder of how far people will go to survive and how much farther they will go with hope of a better life. It’s a monument to the truth and a memento to the forgotten dead."


Like our blog? Please share it!


Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan

Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

China Smart

Essential essays on all things Chinese that inform and entertain travelers, students, and anyone working or living in China

Forty-Seven Samurai

One of the most spectacular vendettas ever: the history and haiku behind the mass-suicide featured in the 2013 film 47 Ronin

Oh, Tama!

A deeply eccentric novel about lives and connections—and a cat of course—in 1980s Tokyo: witty, offbeat, and strangely profound.

Tag Cloud

a memoir foreword indies japan book donald richie evil classic japanese literature author signing drinking in japan japanese classic japanese craft association of jewish libraries traditional a mejiro novel janet pocorbba center of east asian studies china where igo learning in japan jun hazuki fred schodt hitlers cross Japanese literature bowing in japan awards machiya restaurant guide 1960's Japan IBPA learning shamisen film japan etiquette tea the lion king a shameful life verticle china guide american shamisen shun medoruma ancient symbol the japan times writing japanese to english china vacation traditional japanese music keanu reeves anime ibpa publishing university monks wife juddhism mentorship in japan the inland sea Korea review japan food Culture chinese zen monk wife japanese business foreword reviews musical Tokyo Olympics purification comics Ukiyo-e ningen shikkaku kris kosaka japan today kotaku 20th century chinese literature osamu dazai japan travel guide Chinese history Korea photography comic history chinese comics kansuke naka haiku expat in japan kimba the white lion japan memoir china book Spring Festival World War II author talk tomoko aoyama japanese bath a memoir of sensei and me society osamu tezuka manga suehiro maruo finalist gallery awa Travel in the woods of memory Interview kyoto travel sharing a house with the never ending man japanese customs japan guide the millions criterion rebecca otowa peace doris bargen frank beyer nova scotia Japan author tour shamisen performance book reviews anne prescott 4k visitor trip namethetranslator journal' monks wife tracy franz japan travel diymfa 2019 welton gaddy reviews nazi china smart miyazaki japan behavior memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist wanderlust koun japan travel etiquette memoir writing tricycle magazine japan restaurant japanese cutlure hitler symbol forty seven ronin bushido author leonard koren my year of dirt and water japanese travel the fourth string a memoir of sensei and me controversy jing liu state of belief travel to japan amys guide to best behavior in japan learning instruments in japan luke patitsas suicide book hoarding black jack japanese history traditional japanese instrument bookstore xu xu World War Two buddhist swastika catcher in the rye WWII student teacher japan trip announcement The Colorado Review mieko kanai the silver spoon walt disney brad hawley william f sibley expat poetry of consciousness understandind china through comics nhk Children's Books Poetry year of zen china history chapters Olympics japan vacation danica davidson hooked cross how to Children's Literature monk wife disney japan visitor pottery new release Chinese New Year buddhism manga biography forest gander non-fiction min kahng hippocampus magazine symbol journal of a zen monks wife in japan foreword indies award Chiune Sugihara performance janet pocrobba mark gibeau book tour japan custom peace symbol pacific rim review of books book publicity t.k. nakagaki literary prize publicity death 47 samurai hiaku guide classic literature zen monk manners literature japanese book Year of the Dog eastern and western philosophy holden caufield jungle emperor zen miswest book review buddhist symbols memoir foreigner in japan gratitude in japan why we write podcast kinokuniya event huffpost book talk sensei Japanese aesthetics nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara buddhist priest Asian Studies event poet the buddhist swastika studio ghibli studying in japan benjamin franklin awards travel etiquette international book award literary review larry herzberg washington dc damian flanagan alan brill politics and prose wife frederik green china What You Don’t Know, What You Need to Know— A Past & Present Guide to History, Culture, Society, Language asia japanese people oh tama pulitzer prize book signing japanese manners Spirituality Christianity frederik schodt Second World War travel manners China Art/Design education about asia ancient symbols steve heller world literature today publishing tea garden Okinawan literature 1960s Korea amy chavez Basho's Narrow Road internment fantasy literature tourist michael emmerich journal of a zen monk gaijin pot UCLA Shoah gaijin dazai lions roar Coming of Age Day ripe mangoes simba asian review of books kyodo news kyoto guidebook no longer human new york events budhist swastika how to order in japan stone bridge press polite dark horse new york shaimsen japan culture ex pat literature tokyo book zen monks wife' 15 years at studio ghibli osamau tezuka steve alpert buddhist zen monk in japan haibun japanese instruments 47 ronin yukio mishima eli lieberman huffington post Basho japanese translation dirt and water donald keene journal the asian review of books chinese literature interfaith travel literature hong kong Japanese art AAS photography Translation tk nakagaki japanese music book award graphic novels traditional japanese instrumenet stone bridge cafe behavior hiroaki sato japanese forewrod reviews indies university of chicago gaijinpot sensei and me lucille cara author event machiya restaurant Alexandra Johnson japanese drunk diary alan moore japan manners classic translators holocaust nara best behavior in japan podcast religion summer vacation fiction travel Japan seppuku japanese culture japanese books in english henry kiyama books manji book blurb japan times lesley university blurb matcha benjamin franklin award astro boy janet pocorobba green tea shamisen what do in japan VIZ memoir in japan four immigrants takuma sminkey PEN AWARD classic poetry expert japanese instrument Nikolas Bunton living in japan otakuusa award diy mfa koto book reading will eisner Anime/Manga/Comics etiquette Christianity in Japan jared cook new books osaka kyoto journal china travel japan book review Chinese culture giajin 2020 Olympics Japanese holidays monk japanese etiquette japan books rachel manley hate swastika forty seven samurai ritual History amys guide to bes tbehavior in japan zazen japan ravel journal of a zen monk's wife illustration eating in japan the fourth string how to travel in japan the japan society memior japanese books bird talk and other stories astrology kyoto do it right and be polite book review Chinese Astrology the hidden writer Language hitler paul mccarthy