SBP Blog

The difference between Mark Gibeau's and Donald Keene's translation of Osamu Dazai's 'Ningen Shikkaku'

Michael Palmer - Monday, December 10, 2018

A Shameful LifeMark Gibeau's new translation of the Osamu Dazai classic, Ningen shikkaku is finally available. But many are wondering how different is Gibeau's version from Donald Keene's 1948 translation, No Longer Human?

Serdar Yegulalp from Ganriki.org has written an in depth analysis of the two and how they differ from each other, as well as to the original Japanese. 

"The first question people are likely to ask is: If I'm new to No Longer Human, should I start with this version? My short answer is "Probably." Keene's version is slightly more polished as a reading experience, but Gibeau's version is a slightly more faithful translation — there's more of a sense of how Dazai's original sentences and compositions came together on the page, even when they are not necessarily reader-friendly."

Read the full article here: https://www.ganriki.org/article/a-shameful-life/
 

 


Like our blog? Please share it!

Categories

Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan


Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

Easy and Fun Katakana


Learn the second key Japanese syllabary from every angle: reading, writing, and real-world examples.

Exploring Kyoto


This revised and updated edition of the Japan travel classic and cultural guide gets you wandering from downtown quarters to remote mountaintop temples and features expanded information on new museums and gardens now open year-round for viewing.


The Fourth String


Two women. Two cultures. One music.

Tag Cloud

japanese bath nara living in japan japan etiquette book blurb disney sensei and me frederik schodt 2020 Olympics amys guide to best behavior in japan japan restaurant Basho japan books japanese cutlure no longer human book publicity The Colorado Review literary prize zen monk ritual polite how to travel in japan jing liu astro boy Interview a memoir memoir mark gibeau Japan monks wife Korea photography AAS buddhist priest donald keene manga biography fred schodt ningen shikkaku peace suehiro maruo osamu tezuka manners state of belief japanese instruments michael emmerich memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist Chinese New Year author signing japanese travel travel Japan japanese instrument ancient symbols book review asian review of books hooked cross dazai Christianity in Japan tokyo learning shamisen Chinese culture swastika janet pocorobba benjamin franklin award hitler Alexandra Johnson japanese customs sensei t.k. nakagaki osamu dazai VIZ japanese drunk 2019 japan travel in the woods of memory green tea amys guide to bes tbehavior in japan book hoarding catcher in the rye amy chavez the japan society brad hawley holden caufield Japanese literature juddhism kinokuniya event Okinawan literature Year of the Dog washington dc japan behavior ancient symbol Poetry japan culture Japanese art huffington post japanese classic literature behavior Translation shamisen eating in japan Tokyo Olympics haiku guide Spring Festival nazi leonard koren japanese books in english classic japanese literature Shoah books koun Nikolas Bunton understandind china through comics politics and prose announcement welton gaddy reviews tea diary danica davidson musical william f sibley buddhist symbols book award japanese book tea garden Olympics Language etiquette tourist traditional japanese instrumenet memior japanese books china history Asian Studies the millions review eastern and western philosophy astrology japan memoir journal anime shamisen performance osaka shun medoruma award hippocampus magazine world literature today traditional comic history Travel ex pat literature alan brill japanese people japan guide finalist tk nakagaki huffpost buddhism foreword indies Chiune Sugihara japan book manga japanese culture non-fiction graphic novels japan custom giajin author World War Two Children's Books bookstore hate 1960's Japan performance how to order in japan new books author event hitlers cross rachel manley fantasy literature dark horse tracy franz american shamisen Japanese aesthetics asia yukio mishima internment publishing new york zazen book talk best behavior in japan buddhist the hidden writer Spirituality author tour forewrod reviews indies Anime/Manga/Comics evil takuma sminkey event visitor book traditional japanese instrument World War II buddhist swastika new release stone bridge cafe wife kansuke naka UCLA learning in japan comics will eisner PEN AWARD bowing in japan expat History black jack kyoto matcha how to monk wife journal of a zen monk's wife the japan times my year of dirt and water gratitude in japan illustration lions roar religion japanese etiquette book signing China holocaust foreword reviews kyodo news the fourth string walt disney Chinese Astrology japan food Chinese history literary review Basho's Narrow Road publicity seppuku nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara student teacher zen Culture photography stone bridge press WWII 1960s Korea poetry of consciousness Art/Design otakuusa gaijinpot book tour min kahng university of chicago classic Children's Literature Coming of Age Day damian flanagan journal of a zen monks wife in japan henry kiyama Ukiyo-e tricycle magazine chinese comics drinking in japan four immigrants haibun journal' monks wife hiroaki sato Christianity travel to japan IBPA japanese jun hazuki pottery Second World War the buddhist swastika what do in japan alan moore japan trip blurb Japanese holidays japan today jared cook gaijin pot book reading Korea verticle a shameful life suicide center of east asian studies the silver spoon monk purification
RSS