SBP Blog

The difference between Mark Gibeau's and Donald Keene's translation of Osamu Dazai's 'Ningen Shikkaku'

Michael Palmer - Monday, December 10, 2018

A Shameful LifeMark Gibeau's new translation of the Osamu Dazai classic, Ningen shikkaku is finally available. But many are wondering how different is Gibeau's version from Donald Keene's 1948 translation, No Longer Human?

Serdar Yegulalp from Ganriki.org has written an in depth analysis of the two and how they differ from each other, as well as to the original Japanese. 

"The first question people are likely to ask is: If I'm new to No Longer Human, should I start with this version? My short answer is "Probably." Keene's version is slightly more polished as a reading experience, but Gibeau's version is a slightly more faithful translation — there's more of a sense of how Dazai's original sentences and compositions came together on the page, even when they are not necessarily reader-friendly."

Read the full article here: https://www.ganriki.org/article/a-shameful-life/
 

 


Like our blog? Please share it!

Categories

Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan


Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

Easy and Fun Katakana


Learn the second key Japanese syllabary from every angle: reading, writing, and real-world examples.

Exploring Kyoto


This revised and updated edition of the Japan travel classic and cultural guide gets you wandering from downtown quarters to remote mountaintop temples and features expanded information on new museums and gardens now open year-round for viewing.


My Year of Dirt and Water


Married to a Zen monk in training, an American woman in Japan chronicles her own year of growth and discovery.

Tag Cloud

Spring Festival eating in japan asian review of books nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara china history literature zazen eastern and western philosophy bookstore author PEN AWARD huffington post how to Basho's Narrow Road shamisen world literature today the japan times polite photography Nikolas Bunton Second World War hate musical alan brill Spirituality in the woods of memory holocaust buddhist swastika japan food visitor ex pat literature shun medoruma suicide tk nakagaki reviews Travel Year of the Dog juddhism how to travel in japan understandind china through comics China purification Ukiyo-e tracy franz japanese travel Japanese aesthetics buddhist Christianity in Japan travel Japan politics and prose Translation award journal of a zen monks wife in japan Japan Olympics graphic novels Interview monks wife washington dc History japanese customs william f sibley the hidden writer Shoah Okinawan literature seppuku yukio mishima blurb chinese comics Christianity student teacher lions roar otakuusa verticle Children's Books mark gibeau anime guide Korea photography comic history Anime/Manga/Comics tricycle magazine japanese illustration donald keene AAS ningen shikkaku etiquette publishing japan today 1960s Korea koun giajin gaijin pot classic 2020 Olympics japan restaurant religion journal of a zen monk's wife rachel manley book hoarding monk hooked cross swastika tourist Chinese New Year announcement amy chavez leonard koren japanese etiquette astrology japanese bath book blurb Children's Literature japan etiquette janet pocorobba The Colorado Review center of east asian studies non-fiction comics kyoto osamu tezuka bowing in japan World War Two jared cook Language author signing gaijinpot WWII japanese classic university of chicago fred schodt frederik schodt drinking in japan monk wife book tour osaka ritual evil michael emmerich matcha Art/Design four immigrants UCLA poetry of consciousness Basho stone bridge press japanese cutlure gratitude in japan buddhism zen monk the fourth string book publicity the silver spoon min kahng asia japanese people literary prize behavior japanese book japan custom travel to japan Japanese art green tea henry kiyama new york internment suehiro maruo japan memoir journal' monks wife danica davidson japanese culture hitler osamu dazai journal Japanese holidays manga tea VIZ pottery tea garden haibun Coming of Age Day disney jing liu book review the millions buddhist symbols no longer human what do in japan Chinese Astrology classic japanese literature expat sensei Chiune Sugihara japanese drunk japan travel author event how to order in japan zen Korea manners the buddhist swastika nazi review Chinese culture World War II a shameful life Tokyo Olympics peace wife book dark horse takuma sminkey my year of dirt and water book signing memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist Poetry literary review Chinese history Alexandra Johnson publicity stone bridge cafe ancient symbols hiroaki sato new books Japanese literature tokyo Asian Studies kyodo news memoir Culture author tour japan guide huffpost kansuke naka t.k. nakagaki 1960's Japan nara haiku books amys guide to best behavior in japan damian flanagan diary
RSS