SBP Blog

The difference between Mark Gibeau's and Donald Keene's translation of Osamu Dazai's 'Ningen Shikkaku'

Michael Palmer - Monday, December 10, 2018

A Shameful LifeMark Gibeau's new translation of the Osamu Dazai classic, Ningen shikkaku is finally available. But many are wondering how different is Gibeau's version from Donald Keene's 1948 translation, No Longer Human?

Serdar Yegulalp from Ganriki.org has written an in depth analysis of the two and how they differ from each other, as well as to the original Japanese. 

"The first question people are likely to ask is: If I'm new to No Longer Human, should I start with this version? My short answer is "Probably." Keene's version is slightly more polished as a reading experience, but Gibeau's version is a slightly more faithful translation — there's more of a sense of how Dazai's original sentences and compositions came together on the page, even when they are not necessarily reader-friendly."

Read the full article here: https://www.ganriki.org/article/a-shameful-life/
 

 


Like our blog? Please share it!

Categories

Subscribe to the SBP Mailing List

New Releases

Amy’s Guide to Best Behavior in Japan


Going to Japan? This unfussy modern guide guarantees you keep it polite and get it right!

Easy and Fun Katakana


Learn the second key Japanese syllabary from every angle: reading, writing, and real-world examples.

Oh, Tama!


A deeply eccentric novel about lives and connections—and a cat of course—in 1980s Tokyo: witty, offbeat, and strangely profound.

The Fourth String


Two women. Two cultures. One music.

Tag Cloud

japanese books bowing in japan why we write podcast otakuusa new york events fred schodt book reading asia amys guide to bes tbehavior in japan bookstore danica davidson a mejiro novel jun hazuki japan vacation zen zen monk in japan books japan behavior japan today photography japan books tracy franz japan book review japanese drunk japan restaurant state of belief best behavior in japan Second World War japanese instrument manners Japan journal memoir, tracy franz, zen monk, buddhist classic japanese literature lesley university foreword reviews hippocampus magazine astrology huffpost japan culture hitlers cross Ukiyo-e Shoah tourist japanese translation michael emmerich polite literary prize how to japanese culture Art/Design politics and prose Korea william f sibley publishing foreword indies AAS literary review jared cook blurb Coming of Age Day understandind china through comics japanese book Anime/Manga/Comics shamisen diary classic sensei paul mccarthy giajin The Colorado Review Basho's Narrow Road journal of a zen monks wife in japan gaijin pot Translation World War Two world literature today comic history damian flanagan zen monk japanese etiquette diy mfa drinking in japan the buddhist swastika monks wife interfaith Interview Christianity in Japan writing matcha shaimsen buddhist priest monk wife memoir writing ancient symbols the japan times alan moore purification Chinese New Year shun medoruma swastika Christianity jing liu Spring Festival memior the silver spoon japan etiquette VIZ expat forewrod reviews indies journal of a zen monk japanese music student teacher Chinese history the asian review of books japanese travel pacific rim review of books fantasy literature walt disney podcast amys guide to best behavior in japan koun Children's Literature manga Year of the Dog astro boy catcher in the rye a memoir guide foreigner in japan in the woods of memory haiku Japanese literature Travel dazai yukio mishima graphic novels japan food donald keene ibpa publishing university japan guide stone bridge press shamisen performance traditional comics oh tama china history huffington post Alexandra Johnson osaka japanese classic the millions buddhism Japanese aesthetics book reviews 2020 Olympics ex pat literature zazen what do in japan manji book award book tour author signing mieko kanai my year of dirt and water takuma sminkey peace holden caufield the fourth string a memoir of sensei and me wife Language learning shamisen benjamin franklin awards new release China Children's Books hitler religion anime Japanese holidays 1960s Korea Basho living in japan hooked cross announcement seppuku japanese instruments buddhist swastika new books the hidden writer mark gibeau 2019 disney green tea gaijin japanese books in english suehiro maruo japan trip History chinese comics book diymfa ritual tea garden author Nikolas Bunton publicity frank beyer author event juddhism center of east asian studies holocaust pottery Poetry new york memoir tricycle magazine brad hawley osamu tezuka a shameful life visitor year of zen Chinese Astrology the fourth string monk how to travel in japan tea japanese customs travel Japan ancient symbol traditional japanese instrumenet japan book four immigrants frederik schodt gallery awa kyoto travel to japan japan custom Tokyo Olympics book signing Olympics kinokuniya event min kahng musical asian review of books Culture literature Chiune Sugihara amy chavez no longer human tk nakagaki non-fiction stone bridge cafe lions roar washington dc journal of a zen monk's wife poetry of consciousness reviews eastern and western philosophy alan brill koto Korea photography nazi performance kyodo news World War II finalist book hoarding hate sensei and me ningen shikkaku author tour benjamin franklin award IBPA event Chinese culture a memoir of sensei and me journal' monks wife Okinawan literature how to order in japan the japan society UCLA japanese cutlure kansuke naka japanese janet pocrobba t.k. nakagaki japanese craft henry kiyama tokyo rachel manley awards evil nara book talk zen monk wife buddhist hiroaki sato review dark horse book publicity gratitude in japan 1960's Japan book review japan memoir WWII behavior book blurb illustration leonard koren welton gaddy learning in japan japan travel gaijinpot Asian Studies haibun eating in japan PEN AWARD american shamisen verticle japanese people suicide janet pocorobba buddhist symbols nichi bei weekly, naomi hirarahara tomoko aoyama will eisner manga biography black jack university of chicago etiquette japanese bath traditional japanese instrument Spirituality Japanese art award internment osamu dazai
RSS